Sling, Convertible, or 2-in-1: What’s the Best Baby Carrier for You?

baby carrier

Baby Carrier Comparison Table

If you're a first-time parent, you don't care about anything other than your child's safety. Regardless of cost. On the second and third, you have a few tricks up your sleeve. When choosing a baby carrier, security is a primary concern for most parents, and it should be. Manufacturers are implementing many new designs and technologies in their products today. These designs ensure the highest levels of safety for babies. Even if parents don't spend much, they can expect the highest standards of quality in these baby carriers.


Manufacturers also place an importance on safety. So, kids are safe in these baby carriers regardless of their price.

When it comes to choosing a baby carrier and other supplies for your child, you need to consider several factors. Size, safety, comfort (for baby and you), manufacturer, and product styles. As a parent, you also want to choose products that are hypoallergenic and safe for your baby. When the time comes to select the best baby products, the highest prices don't necessarily mean the best quality. So, reconsider your approach as a parent to be when making a short list of the best products available.

Baby Carrier Types

When it comes to buying a baby carrier, parents first have to determine the type/style they are going to buy. A sling baby carrier is a popular option. This product features a soft fabric that wraps around the parent's shoulder. It allows them to carry the baby in front of them, or near the hip. To adjust the sling, a loose piece of fabric near the shoulder will enable parents to change the sling levels. Another common variety of baby carriers is an adjustable carrier. This product can sit in front or fits like a backpack over the parent's shoulder. With most adjustable carriers, the baby can sit facing the parent or away from their parent.

Baby Carrier Selection Process

When parents are choosing a baby carrier, there are several factors to consider. Safety is always the priority. The comfort, usability, and support, are also some things to consider when choosing a carrier.

Head and body support

baby carrier

At an early age, newborns can't support their heads or weight. Therefore, the baby carrier should provide neck and head support to keep the baby safe. Body support is a nice feature in some baby carriers. Interior padding helps support the baby's back and legs. It also creates a more comfortable sitting and sleeping position for babies. Many products also have built-in lumbar support. This feature is great to help maintain form and posture to ensure your child's stability and safety.

Baby carrier adjustability

A wide leg position and ability to vary the carrying position are some features to look for when choosing carriers. Some baby carriers feature a wide area to distribute the baby's weight evenly. This feature is more comfortable for the baby. It also makes it easier for parents to carry children easily as they get older and weigh more. The ability to loosen the shoulder straps is also a nice feature. Parents can reduce stress and give their shoulders a break when carrying their baby for long periods at a time. The ability to vary the center of gravity and positioning are factors to consider when choosing a new carrier.

Baby and parents' comfort

baby carrier

The baby carrier has to be comfortable. If your child is uncomfortable, the experience won't be good for them, or yourself. Soft materials, padding, neck and back support, are some features that'll increase baby's comfort levels. Parents also need to feel comfortable wearing the carrier. One of the biggest complaints is the neck and shoulder tension and pain. Look for a baby carrier with padding, waist straps, and large strap width. Also, choosing a product that allows parents to carry the baby in multiple positions is essential for comfort.

How We Reviewed Baby Carrier Models

We compared sling and adjustable baby carrier models. In our review, we considered the comfort, fit, design, and materials. We also determined the best products utilizing critiques other parents/owners wrote. This first-hand information is influential to other parents. It helps them decide on the best products, and still find the most affordable baby carrier available.

The Best Baby Carrier Slings

When it comes to choosing a baby carrier, affordability is an essential factor for many consumers. These are some of the best, affordable, sling baby carriers available. For those who prefer a sling baby carrier, there are plenty to choose from for your child. Consider material, comfort, adjustability, and pricing when comparing these products.

Boba Baby Wrap Carrier

Boba Baby Wrap Carrier

This sling is best for babies who are zero to three months in age. Owners can safely wash this French terrycloth blended sling in the washer. The material is soft and comfortable for the baby and parents also. This wrap also has spandex in the material blend. So, it doesn't give out or lose resistance over time, like other cloth products.

It features hands-free flexibility and can carry babies weighing up to 35 pounds. Parents can adjust to front and side (hip) infant hold, for maximum levels of comfort. Many reviewers indicate it is difficult and time-consuming to put the sling carrier on their body. In this review, the customer also notes it doesn't feel like they're holding the baby securely.

Boba Baby Wrap Carrier - Original Child and Newborn Sling (Grey)
  • Simple, no-guess tying instructions and just one size make this wrap your GO-TO BABY CARRIER for the first three months of parenthood <3 It was the first of its kind and the simplicity of the idea has kept moms and babies together for 10 years.

Baby K'tan Carrier Wrap

Baby K'tan Carrier Wrap

The wrap is available in sizes xx-small to x-large. Depending on the baby's age and weight, there are multiple sizing options to select. This sling doesn't require any wrapping around the body. And, parents can wear it in five different positions, to ensure comfort for themselves and their baby.

It has an adjustable connector loop to hold it in place. This feature allows parents to adjust the sling, to tighten or loosen it, and guarantee the highest levels of safety. It also provides soft head support to help support the baby's neck, which is essential for younger babies.

Some reviewers indicate it is complex and challenging to put on. Although it does feature multiple position settings, it isn't as straightforward as the manufacturer implies.

Baby K'tan Original Baby Wrap Carrier, Infant and Child Sling - Simple Pre-Wrapped Holder for Babywearing - No Tying or Rings - Carry Newborn up to 35 lbs, Black, Women 10-14 (Medium), Men 39-42.
  • HANDS FREE BABYWEARING: Keep newborn babies, preemies and infants close while you go about your day. Our unique baby wrap design also supports your best position for easy breastfeeding on the go. (If under 8 lbs, consult healthcare professional)

CuddleBug Carrier Sling

CuddleBug Carrier Sling

This ergonomic baby carrier fits snuggly around the baby and parent's body. This sling has a chest-to-chest, hands-free design, so the baby feels secure sleeping in the sling. The soft material is comfortable and doesn't get too warm for babies or parents. It also features an ergonomic design so that parents can adjust for the highest levels of comfort. The sling supports the baby's neck, body, and head, from the close-knit construction.

One reviewer indicates this product is for smaller/petite women/men. It doesn't feature enough cloth to wrap around a larger torso/frame and securely hold the baby in place.

CuddleBug Baby Wrap Sling + Carrier - Newborns & Toddlers up to 36 lbs - Hands Free - Gentle, Stretch Fabric - Ideal for Baby Showers - One Size Fits All (Grey)
  • Carry your baby HANDS FREE! There's nothing in the world that compares to the feeling of a sleeping child against your chest, the sweet-smelling, down-covered head under your nose. In the early days with a newborn, mothers have time to enjoy these moments.

Moby Wrap Baby Carrier

Moby Wrap Baby Carrier

This ergonomic baby carrier fits snuggly around the baby and parent's body. This sling has a chest-to-chest, hands-free design, so the baby feels secure sleeping in the sling. The soft material is comfortable and doesn't get too warm for babies or parents. It also features an ergonomic design so that parents can adjust for the highest levels of comfort. The sling supports the baby's neck, body, and head, from the close-knit construction.

One reviewer indicates this product is for smaller/petite women/men. It doesn't feature enough cloth to wrap around a larger torso/frame and securely hold the baby in place.

Moby Wrap Baby Carrier | Classic | Baby Wrap Carrier for Newborns & Infants | #1 Baby Wrap | Go to Baby Gift | Keeps Baby Safe & Secure | Adjustable for All Body Types | Perfect for Mom & Dad | Black
  • BABY WRAP THAT PROMOTES BONDING: Baby-wearing nurtures a powerful bond that can lead to calm, happy babies, while helping to reduce stress, colic, and even encourage breastfeeding. Less bulky material and padding allows you to keep baby uniquely close, warm, and secure.

Adjustable Baby Carriers

For those who prefer an over-the-shoulder, flexible carrier, there are also several varieties. These are some of the best products to choose from.

Evenflo Breathable Soft Carrier

Evenflo Breathable Soft Carrier

The product is versatile. Babies can sit facing in our outwards to appreciate nature during outdoor strolls. The breathable mesh material ensures they feel comfortable during long walks. The fabric is easy to clean, and there's a removable bib on this baby carrier.

The padding on the back helps increase comfort for babies. The adjustable shoulder straps ensure parents are comfortable as well. A secure, side entry buckle, helps reinforce the baby's weight and creates a safe, secure enclosure.

Some reviewers indicate this product places most pressure on the neck and back for parents. It is adjustable but doesn't evenly distribute weight, which can cause some discomfort.

Evenflo Breathable Soft Carrier, Grey Chevron
  • Product is versatile with 2 carrying positions- baby can face in or out

Baby Steps 6-in-1 Carrier

Baby Steps 6-in-1 Carrier

This baby carrier allows parents to adjust the settings to wear it in six different ways. It can easily carry newborns to toddlers with the durable material finishes. Parents have three front sitting position options with this carrier. They can also wear it as a sling, over the back, or the shoulder. This feature allows parents to dictate the comfort levels/weight distribution when carrying their baby.

This product can carry children from eight to 44 pounds. The built-in, ergonomic design features hip seating at the base. This feature provides the best lumbar support for babies. Since they're sitting in the upright position, it minimizes discomfort in the carrier.

One reviewer indicates some issues with the quality of the product. They state that after only a few uses the zipper broke off of the baby carrier.

No products found.

Infantino Flip 4-in-1 Carrier

Infantino Flip 4-in-1 Carrier

This carrier features four ways for parents to carry their child. Two front-facing positions, one side, and one over the back. A wonder cover and 2-in-1 bib also come with the baby carrier. The seat, legs, and straps are all adjustable.

This product can carry anywhere from eight to 32 pounds. Most parents can use this for newborns and infants. Parents can tailor the seat position from narrow to wide. Depending on the baby's size and weight, this feature ensures the best fit, comfort, and safety for the child.

One reviewer notes this product doesn't have as much padding on the shoulder straps as other products. It also places most weight on the parents' neck and shoulders. This design can lead to pain if parents are wearing the carrier for long periods.

Infantino Flip Advanced 4-in-1 Carrier - Ergonomic, convertible, face-in and face-out front and back carry for newborns and older babies 8-32 lbs
  • Design: 4-in-1 convertible carrier with adjustable ergonomic seat with adjustable shoulder straps and waist belt to shift weight to the wearers hips for a more comfortable fit

Lumiere Baby 6-in-1 Carrier

baby carrier

This baby carrier adjusts from newborn to toddler weight ranges. The company uses a 3D mesh design to increase breathability and comfort. The 360 ergonomic design has six seating positions for babies. Parents can wear the carrier over the front, side, at the hip, or over the back.

It features extra padding and a crossover shoulder design. This design helps with even weight distribution, so it's more comfortable for parents. It also places less tension on their neck and shoulders, which is excellent for long durations of use.

Several reviewers indicate this product isn't safe. One reviewer writes that the product isn't durable. It broke while carrying their child who only weighs 20 pounds. However, the product claims the weight capacity is 45 pounds.

360 Ergonomic Baby Carrier - All Season Baby Sling - 6 Position, Easy Breastfeeding, No Infant Insert Needed, One Size Fits All - Adapt to Newborn, Infant & Toddler. Great Hiking Backpack Carrier
  • ✅ ALL SEASONS - An adjustable temperature-regulation panel allows you to easily control the temperature and keep baby and mom or dad cool or warm depending on the situation; zips-up for warmth and zips-down to reveal cool, breathable, 3D mesh. You'll absolutely love this function! You can save money with the Universal, because it's appropriate all throughout the year so you no longer need to buy both regular and cool mesh baby carriers.

The Best  Convertible and Sling Baby Carrier

Just because you don't have much to spend doesn't mean you can't find a great baby carrier. The best convertible style baby carrier is the BabySteps 6-in-1 carrier. The multiple positions and adjustability are excellent for parents and babies. It also comes in a soft material with padding to help increase comfort for babies. The low price is a significant selling point for this product too. The carrier can hold babies from newborn to nursing, to infant/toddler. So, parents don't have to replace it as often as other products.

Parents who prefer the sling baby carrier also have several great options to consider. The best affordable sling carrier is the CuddleBug carrier. It features a soft material finish and is great for newborns and infants. The ergonomic design allows parents to keep their hands free while wearing the sling. It wraps securely around the baby. The comfortable fit and head support help keep your child safe. The adjustability also allows parents to choose the best fit, to ensure they, and their baby, are comfortable.

It doesn't matter whether you prefer a sling or adjustable baby carrier. There are several great options to choose from as a parent. Consider a few of these when you're narrowing down the list of options for your newborn.

Last update on 2021-06-08 at 15:05 / Affiliate links / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here